30 mars 2008

My cinema: La Zona


La Zona, by Rodrigo Plá, Mexico 2007

La Zona could just be another thriller about people pretending to take ‘justice’ in their own hands. And as usual (unless it is a pure Hollywood movie), things turn wrong. But this film is much more than that. The début film for Mexican director Rodrigo Plá only confirms the good health of Mexican cinema and its realism and dryness. He received a well-deserved prize in Venice for best first film.

La Zona adopts the form of a thriller yet combines it with social political criticism (a bit of a pamphlet), about the social causes of violence in Mexico, although this could happen in many places from Johannesburg to S. Paulo to Malibu. Part of the success is due to the place where i twas filmed, Plá was able to find a natural setting in Mexico well adapted for this film… those sub-urban condominiums where all houses are identical and follow very strict rules, almost as among the habitants of the community in the film.


The film starts following the codes of a classical Hollywood thriller, from where he borrows the narrative capacity, but slowly that logic changes and Plá achieves to escape the apparent Manichaeism. The film then takes unexpected turns (as when we were thinking that the police were the ‘good guys’) to denounce criminal social practices, police corruption and social differences and the criminal tendency of certain rich and powerful to place themselves above the law. At the end there is no certitude and nothing is crystal clear, doubt is installed and then ends in a heavy way, making it a film you won’t forget easily. Excellent. [4.5/5]

28 mars 2008

My cinema: new review

Vantage Point by Pete Travis, USA 2008

Vantage Point could have been an interesting thriller. But after a mildly promising start showing eight different points of view of different protagonists (view angles) it gets lost in unlikely action and the typical scenes from Hollywood B series like cars chasing each other in the streets of Salamanca. The plot is not too original and also very unlikely not to say ridiculous. The question is, what are actors like William Hurt, Sigourney Weaver, Forest Whitaker and Eduardo Noriega doing there (well okay I can understand about Dennis Quaid and Matthew Fox…). Maybe for a dvd home view in a boring evening. [1/5]

01 mars 2008

My Cinema

Paris, by Cedric Klapisch, France 2008

After "L'Auberge espagnole" and "Russian Dolls", Klapisch films "PARIS", a drama-comedy, ode to his beloved city. He focuses again on some of his favourite elements like Paris (already a main character of some of his earlier films (Chacun Cherche son chat), neighbourhood life, “romantic angst”, crossed storylines and… featuring Romain Duris. PARIS is likeable and entertaining but fails however to impress and bring something new. It is well filmed with some interesting sequences such as the opening introduction and is supported by a high level cast in particular Juliette Binoche and Fabrice Luchini. There’s the feeling that much of it is a bit contrived and forced and a bit of a tourist publicity spot, despite some great images of the City of lights served by a good soundtrack (Wax Tailor’s Seize the day, Eric Satie's "Gnossienne No. 3." Etc). Very watchable particularly if you happen to love Paris, like me. And some could see here a parallel to Woody Allen’s "MANHATTAN" knowing that Klapisch has written his thesis on him [3/5]

This is England, by Shane Meadows, UK 2007

It seems that Shane Meadows films here a nearly autobiographical picture about skinheads and would-be skinheads. This story is set in the early eighties of Thatcherism, with the Falklands war in the background. It is a sometimes funny drama about the white working classes left out of the promised Britain’s economy prosperity and alienated with the triumph of the Falklands victory that ends up to violence. This is British cinema at its best and therefore contained and not soapy at any stage. Great acting as well in particular the excellent lead performance by 13-year-old newcomer Thomas Turgoose (as Shaun). [4/5]